A perect circle Judith

[Coogan 1st MRB]

if you havnt heard of a perfect circle and are a tool fan then im ashamed ps the bassist is hot

Original

My fav cover

[Goodwin 1st MRB]

well.... that song is probably 10+ years old.

I don't even know if A Perfect Circle is still together! But I love them.

Seriously - Keenan is my favorite! He's amazing. Tool is amazing, so is APC.

[Goodwin 1st MRB]

Oh yea, interestingly enough, if you listen you hear her sining the backing vocals.

I have tried and tried to tell Dobbles you can hear her, he still claims to this very day (I don't know if he has ever seen this video) that there is NO backing vocals.

Anyhow... this song is based on Maynerd James Keenans disbelief in God at that particular time...

His mom however was an AVID believer, and never gave up until the day she died.

If you listen to the lyrics he talks about 'what did he ever do for you', and all this stuff relating directly to his mom and her beliefs and how he thinks God has abandoned her. She was like paralyzed giving birth to him or something.

One of their follow up albums was titled 10,000 days - which equates to 23 years or something... which is how many years his mom lived afters he was paralyzed.

This song is the beginning of of 2 songs dedicated to how he realizes his mothers beliefs are okay and he accepts her beliefs and hopes God takes her to a better place:

Wings for Marie (his mom)

part of the lyrics state (in reference to his previous disdain for his mothers religious beliefs):

Those moments that I wouldn't see

Cause you, you pray for me too

What have I done to be a son to an angel

What have I done to be worthy

This is Pt. 2

I love his singing.

[Coogan 1st MRB]

ive loved tool apc since a was in grade 5 or 6 tool is my favorite of all time maynard is a fucking god and yes i know what the song is about judith was his mother and apc a hace currently got back together and are touring

oh and wings of marie part one a 2 are my favs songs by tool