"Rate the sig above you" thread...

[A. Cannon 1st MRB]

8/10

Really like photo from movies and a great message!

[C. Small 1st MRB]

7/10 be better if it was a frenchman

[T. Brown 1st MRB]

9.5/10

- Extremely aesthetically pleasing with the orange/brown/red color theme coordination

- Text is prominent and easily readable

- Quote is a clever reconstruction of the phrase "I do not give a shit", so pretty original.

Only lost .5 points for that small white text; seems out of place and distracts from what would otherwise be a perfect signature.

[Jablonski]

7/10 i guess its original but i just dont know what to think when looking at it other than "its brown".

[J. Johnson]

9/10 - Loving the flames, nice!

[Reis 1st MRB]

8/10 love them chicks

[Yamagata 1st MRB]

8/10 No clutter, no nonsense, well blended, and I just love the Platoon Pride.

[Gardner2]

10/10 because its Yamagata's signature and he rocks all around all the time!!!! And the rest pale in comparism!!!!

[Gearhart 1st MRB]

6/10 - not my style why have the website when the signature is used on the website? heh.

[Willow 1st MRB]

7/10 simple and uncluttered

[Cribari]

8/10 simple but effective.

[Gardner2]

8/10 I like it

6/10 - not my style why have the website when the signature is used on the website? heh.

Because I use it on other websites to advertise silly.

Edited July 29, 2013 by Gardner 1st MRB

[C. Small 1st MRB]

9/10

how could you not like it , would be 10/10 if they were neked

[Candy 1st MRB]

Well, what can be said..its.....Small.

The contrast is excellent between background and text

The phrase is catchy, and fits the unit member to a "T"

The graphic is well placed on the left and offsets the text well on the right.

I'd give it a 9/10

Edited August 13, 2013 by Candy 1st MRB

[Pinion]

9/10. It made me laugh!

I just got this badass new sig. What'choo guys think?

[T. Brown 1st MRB]

9.8/10.

Excellent color themes, subdued and grey, an impeccable depiction of what war is. The text in the quote follows the same standards, reminding one of the damaged buildings left after a battle and echoing the sentiments of the quote itself. All in all, a fantastic signature.

I too just got a new bad ass sig, do me!

[Pinion]

Thank you, Brown!

20/10.

Dead wizards? Check.

Yawns? Check.

Yawning fox? Check.

Catsquirrel? Check.

Brown's name? Check.

1st MRB logo? Check.

That's basically my universal checklist for rating signatures. You pass!

Edited August 22, 2013 by A. Pinion 1st MRB

[Gearhart 1st MRB]

Bump. Cool design and font compliments the spray. 8/10

[Hansen 1st MRB]

Great effects and the font suits it well. 9/10

[J. Hill]

8.5 Like the colors and how the name has scratches and pieces missing from it. Looks very kool.

[Lystad 1st MRB]

I'd say 9/10! It looks nice.

Edited October 31, 2015 by Lystad 1st MRB

[S. Hill]

9.7/10. it gives a truth of life, and shows the path with a sun always on one side for it either rises or falls on that side of the path you walk. =)